Friday, February 26, 2010

Some recent relevant articles in the Pioneer

In "No Clean Yamuna in time for Games>", Sheela Dixit, the "mayor" of Delhi is having to counter charges from the BJP that money earmarked for Yamuna cleaning is going to the right places. At any rate, cleaning the Yamuna is on the radar in the Delhi news and editorial pages. Here is a summary of the situation as reported in the Pioneer a couple of days ago. The Yamuna is today what the Thames was 150 years ago. That article is posted below in full.

On a more hopeful note, Ravi Shankar is participating in the move to get the Yamuna cleaned up. BVHA activists should take note and approach Ravi Shankar at the Hardwar Kumbha Mela, where he will be in a couple of weeks.

Yamuna Expressway to be eight lanes. The same company building the bridge by Keshi Ghat is constructing the expressway linking Noida to Agra, and beyond, it seems. That project is encountering difficulties of another sort. Taking Dalit lands for expressway.



Yamuna today is what Thames was 150 yrs ago


Malvika Baru Sharma | New Delhi (The Pioneer)

The river Yamuna, having been declared dead with its water all poisonous from 22 drains from all over Delhi feeding 800 million gallons of sewage into it per day, can kill a healthy human being. It's the rapid industrialisation that is helping the inevitable pollute to the river, pointed out Robert Oates, Director, Thames Rivers Restoration Trust (TRRT), and the industrial revolution of India is 10 times that of England when it took place.

"It is not just Government's but every citizen of Delhi's responsibility to make sure that the river's cleanliness is restored and its purity revived," he said. The Indian National Trust For Art and Cultural Heritage (INTACH) South Asia Network for Dams, Rivers & People (SANDRP), Toxics Link and Yamuna Jiye Abhiyan (YJA) organised a lecture by Robert Oates of TRRT in the Capital on Tuesday.

In a presentation, the TRRT detailed how the whole Thames river restoration project was undertaken. TRRT is an independent charity in the UK dedicated to improving the Thames river in London and its tributaries to benefit people and nature and it has done some pioneering work in recent years. Robert explained that what all difficulties TRRT had to face 150 years back will not be faced by Delhi's governance with all its knowledge and technical advances like GIS at their behest. "It might not take as long as 50 years for the whole restoration project of Yamuna. It might take even less than 15 years if all goes to plan," he said.

Yamuna today is what London's Thames was 150 years ago, with all its water polluted almost irrevocably. It seemed impossible to restore it to its natural state, but it was good governance that brought life back to the river. Oates was there to share all the experiences of his to revive the Thames and if there were any lessons for the efforts to help revive the river Yamuna in Delhi. SK Mishra, Chairman, INTACH, Ramaswamy Iyer and Manoj Mishra of YJA pointed out along with Oates the right measures that should be undertaken to improve the health of Yamuna. The drains dumping the sewage and the encumbered water flow are the two major causes that impede the river.

"There are just 17 sewage treatment plants which are not functioning to their designed capacity, to serve the drains feeding 1,200 km of the Yamuna... Instead, the Government is investing 1,500 crore rupees on an interception treatment plant which is not even capable of treating the sewage," said the presentation.

Thanks to Anant M. Vyas for the head's up on that article.

Is this Vrindavan's future?

Thursday, February 25, 2010

I just don't get it...


I recently received the following letter from a devotee who doesn't get what the problem is with the bridge going by Keshi Ghat. Actually, he is not the only one, but many seem to be confused about the fuss. On the one hand, there are those with materialist vision, who see the bridge as "progress" that will bring Vrindavan into the 21st century. On the other are the devotees who think we should passively attempt to change our vision and see the divine Vrindavan while pretending that whatever happens on the surface is irrelevant to the way that our vision is transformed. Here is his letter and my answer:
I just don't get it. Why is everyone so concerned with the environment? It is our master, we must accept what the environment is doing and carry on in our devotional practices.

I was just in Vrindavan, it was wonderful, words cannot do justice. My condolences to all of you people concentrating on some material matter. You should be concentrating on the beauty.

If you find a rock in your rasagulla you savor your tooth breaking rather than the sweetness of the rasagulla, and then you blame that on the sweetmaker.

Vrindavan will be beautiful with or without a bridge.

I don't know about you people but I know that I don't have the devotion to see that true transcendental Vrindavan, all I see is dust and stool. A bridge is much nicer to look at than stool.

If you can see that REAL Vrindavan, then please bestow upon me your mercy so that I too may see what is REALLY there, so that I may see the lord of my heart with my own eyes. Until I get sufficient devotion and mercy I will not see, so please bestow upon me your mercy.
The letter is a little confused, since in the beginning you seem to be ignoring the stool and then you say that you do see it, but that you find the bridge beautiful. At any rate, you fail to see the connection between the two.

But to answer your question as to how to get the devotion and mercy so that you can see the REAL Vrindavan, let me give you a few tips.

If your heart is impure and full of desires, do you engage in purificatory acts to make it proper for Krishna to reside there, or not?

Similarly, if your temple were dirty, would you not think it necessary or appropriate to clean it? Should the deities be nicely dressed and offered food on clean dishes, and so on?

Did Mahaprabhu set an example in the Gundicha temple, or did he say, "Jagannath likes it this way" and leave it? And is it a devotional practice, mandira-mArjanAdau, or not?

And when Narottam Das cleaned Lokanath Goswami's stools, why didn't he just say, "My guru's body is transcendental. His stools, like Rishabhadeva's, smell like roses. So I will revel in his stool; there is no need to clean them"?

Actually, you are making the Ramachandra Puri mistake. When Madhavendra Puri was dying and calling out in separation to Radha and Krishna, Ramachandra Puri said, "What's your problem? You are a liberated soul. Why are you crying out in separation?" Ishwar Puri recognized the opportunity for service and got Madhavendra Puri's mercy, while Ramachandra Puri's career spiralled downwards.

When Raghunath or Prabodhananda say that they dream of sweeping the Divine Couple's pleasure bower, is that incorrect of them? Are they concentrating on some material matter because they clean the kunja?

Furthermore, if someone comes to your parents' house and desecrates it--let us say they come and drink alcohol and urinate in the living room--do you just ignore it and see the spirit soul in them and accept that they are acting according to the modes of nature and leave whatever filth or nuisance they have done without question? Is Vrindavan your home or not?

So is cleaning the environment in the Dham service to the environment or service to Guru, Gauranga and Gandharvika-Giridhari?

If you do not see the dirt, then you are exempt from cleaning it. But I would say, that is your misfortune. Your guru has not shown you that this service is there to be done.

He probably told you to sell books. Why? Isn't everybody already eternally liberated and never separated from Radha and Krishna?

And when you walk on the parikrama marga, I assume you don't hear the cars honking and nearly running you over. And when the bridge is built and there are ten times as many cars, you will neither notice the fumes or the increased noise. Better be careful, as one of those cars you neither see nor hear, may run you over. But of course, there is no difference between life and death, is there?

My dear friend, in fact, you are very fortunate that you have had a positive experience of Vrindavan. We wish that everyone else should also have as wonderful a pilgrimage to this land as you have had.

Believe me, for those of us who have been coming to or staying in Braj for the last 35 or 40 years, we continue to come because we also see the transcendental beauty pervading the land, and because we can feel the presence of Radha and Krishna here. That is precisely why we feel this need to preserve and enhance the special, sacred and spiritual character of Vrindavan, and feel it a necessary act of PREACHING to do so.

Preaching is not just selling books. Preaching is also about creating an environment that is conducive for devotional service. Nowhere in the world, no temple, no ashram, is as important a place for devotional service as the place where Radha and Krishna had their pastimes.

That is why Chaitanya Mahaprabhu sent Sri Rupa and Sanatan there, not to convert anyone, but to discover and reveal the holy places where the Divine Couple had their pastimes. This was part of their PREACHING mission. Braj was that important to Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. And so, one of the first things he did when he had stalwart and worthy disciples was to send them to Braj to do this.

When these places get lost again, or inundated under a ton of garbage, or paved over to make a four-laned highway, we will be letting Rupa and Sanatan's service be undermined. How can that be pleasing to Chaitanya Mahaprabhu? We will have misunderstood a great deal about bhakti and prema-rasa.

Rupa Goswami's "upadesha-sara", "the essence of all instruction," is to live in Vrindavan under the shelter of a rasika devotee and hear and chant about Radha and Krishna's most intimate pastimes, i.e., to do bhajan and meditate on the ashta-kaliya lila. You may not be ready to do that, nor may many others, but Vrindavan and the other places in Braj Dham should be developed in such a way that this is the ideal environment to do just that.

Sadhus naturally want a peaceful, beautiful, sacred environment to do their bhajan. Where will they go if this place is ruined for bhajan? Is there an alternative to Vrindavan? Can we make a New Vrindavan that is as good as the old one?

There is no alternative. We must serve and preserve the Holy Dham that Rupa and Sanatan, and Haridas Swami, and Vallabhacharya, and Hit Harivams, and Hari Vyasa, and the acharyas of all the rasika sampradayas chose as their place of bhajan. We have no choice. NONE.

Jai Sri Radhe!!

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Court case, Part II

Dear devotees, Radhe Radhe!!

At today's hearing, the Court has asked the State Government how it is that the funds for the bridge construction work were sanctioned and distributed when the Tourism Master Plan of Vraj Region (Vrindavan Samagra Vikas Pariyojana) has not yet been sanctioned? An answer as to why the construction work was started without obtaining a no objection certificate from the Apex Court was also demanded.

The court also issued notices to several government departments and asked them to respond. A second hearing is set for the 29th of March.

Please keep praying to Shri Radha and Krishna to save our Yamuna Maharani.

Yours in the service of Vrindavan
Chandan Goswami

Spokeperson
Yamuna Vrindavan Heritage Foundation
Braj Vrindavan Heritage Alliance



Court No. - 9

Case :- PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION (PIL) No. - 2593 of 2010

Petitioner :- Madhu Mangal Shukla

Respondent :- Union Of India Thru. Secr. Ministry Of Environment and Others
Petitioner Counsel :- A. Chaturvedi, Amit Verma, G.N. Verma

Respondent Counsel :- A.S.G.I.,C.S.C. (2010/2052), D.S. Chauhan, Dr. Ashok Nigam, Rajesh Mishra, Hon'ble Vijay Manohar Sahai, J., Hon'ble Ritu Raj Awasthi, J.

Learned Standing Counsel has raised objection that certain necessary parties are not impleaded in the writ petition.

Learned counsel for the petitioner is permitted to implead the Principal Secretary, Finance, Govt. of U.P. Lucknow, Principal Secretary, Public Works Department, Lucknow, U.P. Engineer-in-Chief, Public Works Department, U.P. Lucknow, Chief Engineer, Public Works Department, Agra Zone, Agra, Executive Engineer, Public Works Department, Mathura as well as the contractor M/s Jai Prakash Associates, through its Managing Director, r/o Sector 128, Noida, Gautambudh Nagar in the array of the parties during the course of the day.

Issue notice to newly added respondents.

Notice on behalf of the State has been accepted by Sri G.C. Upadhyaya, learned Standing Counsel. Notice on behalf of M/s Jai Prakash Associates, Sector 128, Noida, Gautambudh Nagar, through its Managing Director has been accepted by Sri Yashwant Verma, Advocate.

Counter affidavit on behalf of Respondent No.8 has been filed by Sri V.C. Mishra, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Sri D.S. Chauhan, it is taken on record.

Rest of the respondent nos. 1 to 7, 9 & 10 and newly added respondents no. 11 to 16 shall also file the counter affidavit by the next date fixed clearly explaining the points as mentioned in the earlier order dated 21.01.2010.

In case the other respondents including the newly added respondents do not file the counter affidavit then they shall appear before this Court in person and show cause as to why they are not filing the counter affidavit.

The counter affidavit shall also be sworn by Chief Secretary, Govt. of U.P. as well as Principal Secretary, Finance, Govt. of U.P. explaining therein when Vrindavan Samagra Vikas Pariyojana, Tourism Master Plan of Vraj Region, has not yet been sanctioned then how the funds for the aforesaid construction work has been sanctioned and distributed as mentioned in paragraph 27 of the writ petition. It shall further been explained as stated in paragraph 18 that Vrindavan comes under the Taj Trapezium Zone then why the construction work has been started without obtaining any no objection certificate from the Apex Court before starting construction. Other respondents shall also swear their counter affidavits.

Learned Standing Counsel is also directed to file the contract entered into between the State Government and J. P. Associates along with counter affidavit.

List on 29.03.2010.

Office is directed to handover the copy of this order today to Sri G. C. Upadhyaya, learned Standing Counsel for information and ensuring the compliance of the order.

Order Date :- 23.2.2010

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Global Kirtan

Here are a couple of photos from the January 30 kirtan at Keshi Ghat. The high point for me certainly came with Shyam Das's kirtan after the arti ceremony itself. A very sophisticated and moving performance, done under the lights, with floating deepas speckling the darkness in the background. It felt like a campfire, but very intimate and very transcendental, with a small but enthusiastic group in the audience.

There were many participants throughout the day, particularly featuring members of the Vrinda organization. Notable was a very enthusiastic kirtan led by Deenabandhuji, who is the main source for the pictures here. Ahindra came from Iskcon with his group in the afternoon, and provided another patented Ahindra kirtan, which drew many people on the steps. On the whole a very enjoyable day.

Krishnadevata Dasi must be commended for organizing the global kirtan effort, which brought together devotees at more than 230 sites around the world. Her Facebook page is here and the Global Kirtan Webpage is also available for further information.



Many people were walking through Keshi Ghat on parikrama, as this was one of the Kumbha Mela Shahi Snanas. Some of them stopped to listen and enjoy the kirtan.


Paramadvaiti Maharaj is the steadiest and most consistent voice for sanity in Gaudiya Vaishnavism, at least from the social and institutional standpoint. His disciples are committed, humble and enthusiastic. A great credit to him and I offer them all my obeisance.



Things are quieting down a bit, as expected, but I hope that the concern for Vrindavan's future will not abate. The petitions still need signing, so please do not neglect that aspect of things.




More stuff here: Yamuna Vrindavan Heritage Foundation. Please note the posters that are downloadable for printing. This site has many pictures which make a truly excellent slideshow presentation. It shows Vrindavan as it was 20 years ago, as it is now.


Thursday, February 18, 2010

Rishikesh Promenade

Since I posted some pictures of Hardwar, I thought I would crosspost some other photos from a Facebook album of the new promenade being built in Rishikesh, which makes it possible to stroll nonstop all the way from Lakshman Jhula to the Barrage, roughly 10 kilometers downstream, without any vehicle traffic whatsoever.

At the same time, at Triveni Ghat, which is right downtown, the Ganga bed is being diverted to come closer to the ghat itself. In recent years, the water only reaches the steps during the rainy season. Now it will be possible to descend the steps into the holy river all year round.

It looks to me that some good ideas are available here for the Vrindavan parikrama marg, if anyone can get the message across.


This picture shows how the digging of the new channel is progressing. The central portion, where the backhoe is digging, is to be entirely removed, according to the engineers that I met there.


Here is the famous Bhagavad Gita statue at Triveni Ghat.


Spotted along the promenade are these lookout cupolas in an art deco style with wrought iron, very nice.


Further downstream, you get an idea of how the pathway is being used or abused. There is a Gangeshwar temple about one kilometer downstream from Triveni Ghat. Here they were putting on a Shiva Purana Saptaha. Since the walkway is not yet heavily used, it is not much of an inconvenience.


Here you can see further downstream, towards the end of the promenade. The Rajaji National Park is on the other side, offering a rare and beautiful vision of greenery.


A good idea: Providing pumps along the way so that tourists can get a drink.

Haridwar Waterfront

I just thought I would post these pictures showing how Haridwar has arranged its Ganga area. It is quite nicely done and could be seen as a reference for how things could be done at Vrindavan.

This first picture is taken from the gondola lift to Manasa Devi. You can see the old Ganga bed on the far side and the canal segment running next to the town. There are actually several channels and hydroelectric generators in more than one location. But the organization of the waterways has been effective. The main highway runs in between them, but there is also a nice green park in that space. The main Kumbha Mela tent city is on the far side of the bridge that crosses the Ganga to the upper left of the picture.


This picture is taken from the Hardwar city side looking toward the above mentioned green area between the canal and old Ganges bed. Ghats line both sides of the canal. Since the hills run quite close to the river, the town is quite narrow. The market section is in the Harki Pauri area. In both directions away from Harki Pauri there are hundreds of ashrams, some quite prosperous, as well as hotels, etc.


The image below shows a painted slogan on the ghat wall. It says "India's soul resides in its holy places. India's development lies in the development of her holy places."


Looking upstream from a bridge, the name of which I forget. There are quite a few bridges crisscrossing the canal portion of the Ganga, which is where most of the bathing goes on. Many were built just for the Kumbha and most are for pedestrian traffic alone. Most come to bathe at Harki Pauri, which is in this direction but cannot be seen on the photo.


Looking downstream from the same bridge. The park is on the left side. You can see there are many bridges--even more have been built to facilitate bathing for the Kumbha Mela. It gives an almost Budapestian flavor to the site.

Bridges in themselves are not a problem. The problem with the Keshi Ghat bridge is that it defaces the architectural and natural beauty of Vrindavan, as well as destroying the relationship of the pilgrim to the sacred character of the town. Here, the contrary has been achieved.


Another view from the same ghat as above.


Here is a scene of the original Ganga bed, with donkeys bringing stones across.


On the whole, I was quite favorably impressed by Haridwar. Clearly a great amount of money has come in for the Kumbha Mela, but the money appears to have been well used. There are still spots that are glaringly unkept, but much of the riverfront is in good condition and is being kept clean.

Both Haridwar and Rishikesh are showing signs of development that both demonstrates an awareness of pilgrim tourism and the enhancement of their natural beauty. In both places, car traffic is kept away from the waterfront areas and sufficient space is being set aside for peaceful promenades.

If only Vrindavan could take inspiration and develop its Parikrama Marg with the same philosophy. The topography naturally favors this kind of development in Rishikesh and Haridwar, nevertheless, it is the end result we must look at.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

My walk to Keshi Ghat

Sometimes time really does seem to fly, and one barely knows where it went. Certainly on the trip to Vrindavan, two entire days were lost in traveling. May I never take the Utkal Express again.

Got into Vrindavan well after midnight. Was up late in the morning, but started off immediately for Keshi Ghat. As usual, it was a dreadful shock to see the garbage piled up in the old ghats, the running nalas overflowing onto the road, and general mess and neglect. You can see here and here that even in India, it does not have to be so. You can see pictures of the kind of situation that prevails on the Yamuna Vrindavan Heritage Alliance website. Just scroll down through this slideshow to get an idea.

On the way, I noticed that there was activity at one of the sewage treatment plants along the Parikrama Marga, so I stopped in to see what the story was. The engineer there told me first of all that the plant was functioning. I asked him whether the pipes that had been laid throughout the western part of the town came through to his plant and he said they would eventually, but that at present they did not get that far. Furthermore, since the pipes were inadequate to the task, being too small, the whole job would have to be done over again.

Now this sounds to me like the most egregious bit of incompetence that I have ever heard of. A huge sum of money was given to do this bit of essential infrastructure work and due to corruption (I have no doubt whatsoever that this is the case) the money has been frittered away and the Vrindavan streets are left in complete disarray, resulting in regular accidents, broken axles and bent wheels on rickshaws, etc., etc.

The other day I took a rickshaw ride from Vrinda Kunj to Bhakti Dham, and on the way, the rickshaw's front wheel took a whack on a rugged piece of road, and the driver had to take a detour to the repairman. It cost him 40 Rs, exactly what I was paying him. That is the situation.

I regularly berate the rickshaw wallas, many of whom are Bengalis, for not demonstrating to the Municipal authorities to protest. Why don't they block the streets to call attention to the corruption and the mismanagement of these public works projects? They are surely among the most affected.

They tell me this is not Marxist West Bengal, where the little man at least gets a voice. Here, no one listens to the lowest of the low, especially not if they come from out of state. Bengalis are not held in great esteem. Too bad that one who was, Nimai Maitra, the prominent local RSS leader, just died recently. He might have intervened.

Someone told me the laughing-in-my-beard story the other day about a rickshaw ride she had taken. They came to one of these dug up streets and she decided to get down to at least make it easier for the wallah to get over the hump. As they were going through the rocky patch, they passed a poor rickshaw driver who was struggling with a vehicle overflowing with no less than five well-endowed pilgrims from Delhi or somewhere. My friend started to berate the group asking them whether they had no consideration and could they not see what their driver was having to go through. Before the dumbstruck group could answer, the rickshaw's axle broke, the carriage overturned and the five chubby Indians fell into the muddy street.

It would have been a jolly good Schadenfreude laugh, except that the thoughtless privilegiés immediately started to blame the hapless rickshaw wallah for the disaster. Of course, he did not get paid and was stuck with the bill for repairs. Not a good day for him.

On my way to Vrindavan, I had the pleasure to accompany a group I encountered accidentally in the waiting room in Hardwar (our train was delayed 8 hours). Sankirtan Das, a Swiss devotee who has been living in China for the last 20 years and speaks fluent Chinese, was with a group of 10 people from a city outside Beijing, maybe Tongzhon. Sankirtan Dasji has written a book, which has also been translated into Chinese, called Bhakti Yoga Pilgrimage. He has been running tours like this for some time.

The leader of the group, a striking woman with the given name Kunti, is the owner of 15 (!) yoga centers in her town and most of the others in the group were teachers in those centers. They had spent a few days in Rishikesh, at Madhuvan, doing yoga and looking around.

The Chinese pilgrims were very sweet. Sankirtan told me they had spent part of the previous day in Hardwar doing kirtan at Harki Pauri, which had attracted a great deal of attention, as you can imagine. We also spent a few hours on the train doing kirtan. The man is indeed true to his name.

Anyway, since many of the Chinese wear glasses, I was warning them about the Vrindavan monkeys. I told them about how the last time I had been with Paramadvaiti Maharaj in Vrindavan, out behind the Rangaji temple, a monkey had stolen his glasses and had simply mashed them to bits in full view of everyone.

It used to be that in Vrindavan there were only a few places where monkeys stole people's glasses. I have good experience of this. The main places were at Chir Ghat and in front of the Shahji Mandir near Loi Bazar and Radha Raman. There may have been other places, but those two I know about. At Shahji Mandir one time I was even in a rickshaw and a monkey flew past me, picking off my specs. The thing was that the monkeys and the local residents had a kind of symbiotic relationship. The monkey would steal the glasses, the Brajvasis would have chola and other goodies at the ready, they would offer the monkey a bribe, which the clever creature happily accepted, dropping the glasses. A local youth (as it was usually young men and kids who would be competing for the prize) would then offer them back to the owner and get a reward--50 to 100 rupees.

But in Paramadvaiti Maharaj's case, the monkey had somehow learned the first part of the lesson, "I monkey. Steal glasses." But had not learned the second part, "Get food. Drop glasses." The learned behavior is spreading through Vrindavan's monkey community, but the parampara has been broken in the course of time, kaleneha mahata yogo bhrashtaH parantapa.

Now I was to encounter the same situation. As I approached Chir Ghat, I began to think that it would be wise to take my specs off. But when your eyesight is as bad as mine, you tend to want to wait to the last moment. Perhaps all the construction that is there has driven the predatory beasts further afield, who knows, but I waited too long. A large monkey leaped past me, and with barely the sense of being touched, only the whiff of a breeze, my nose was naked.

And there was no one around to come to my rescue. No Brijbasis with biscuits for the beast. I ran to get biscuits and came back, blind as a bat and unable to even see where the evil creature had gone. Someone pointed him out, sitting atop a wall, meditatively crunching away at my ocular prosthesis. I threw him as many biscuits as I could, but the wicked beast looked at me with indifference. A crowd of his progeny danced around picking up the crumbs, and when I let down my hand in despair, another snatched the remaining biscuits from my hand. Such is the new treachery of these maleficent anthropoids. Don't call them mischievous, they are a menace.

And so, taking it that I had been delivered by Radharani herself from seeing the hulking skeleton of a half-moon bridge and the rest of the disasters that it had brought to the area, I walked on towards Keshi Ghat for the kirtan. I stopped just to talk to a few of the inactive construction workers who were hanging about. They said, "The work has only stopped temporarily. There is an nefarious rich lady in Keshi Ghat who is manipulating the powers-that-be to deprive us of our jobs, but our bosses have assured us it is only for one month."

So that's the situation. Katie Jo Walter and others are working very hard to get the court case on the 23rd prepared, thinking of all arguments that could come up and how to counter them. Let us keep on praying. Some people are thinking of doing another kirtan on that day, so I ask you to do so. It may not be as public and well-publicized as the Global Kirtan on the 30th, but do not forget this work. It is not something that can be done in one or two days. We need to keep on praying, chanting, asking Srimati Radharani to intervene so that we can build up our strength, chase away the destructive materialistic forces and recreate Vrindavan in a way that does an honor to our beloved Yugal Kishore.

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

BVHA Meeting Minutes, Feb. 7, 2010

Attendees:
Jagannath Poddar
Malti
Kesava Das Swami
Swami BP Madhusudan
Shubhananda Das
Sevak Sharan
Arup Govinda Das
Nirguna Devi Dasi
Manjari Devi Dasi
Karan Rajeev
Madhusudan
Pt. Udayan Sharma
Madhumangal Shukla

B.A. Paramadvaiti opened the meeting with a call to re-estabish commitment for BVHA, asking all to vow to sustain the unity required and not let it fall – be sensitive, apologize – always keep big picture in mind – put aside ego.

B.A. Paramadvaiti Visited Rang ji Mandir mahant – he was almost crying saying that for 150 yrs he been using Yamuna water for pujas and finally had to stop because it was so dirty.

He also got support from Brahma Kund Goswami and the acharya for Gopeshwar Mandir
Madhusudan Maharaj spoke to Ramesh Baba – 11th Ramesh Baba will demonstrate at DM’s office in Mathura and wants Vrindavan to join him.

Ramesh Baba will host a sadhu samelan in his tent on the 17th. BVHA should prepare a presentation.

The Vishwa Hindu Parishad will be represented at the Sadhu Sammelan - investigators came to see situation in Vrindavan.

What subjects discussed on 17th?
-heritage status
-bridge
-cleanup/pollution

Gill supported Ashok Singhal (VHP) meeting. Ashok Singhal said he can get all spiritual leaders to Lucknow to protest & friends w/ Mayawati

It was noted that Mayawati might get angry at VHP involvement in the issue
The suggestion was made to present Mayawati with an alternative plan and send her a letter saying that we (BVHA) are not against her, we want to help.

If anyone would present this to her, it would be Madhusudan & Sevak Sharan.

Manjari Devi Dasi: thought lawyer, Gill should be consulted – could be counter-productive to approach Mayawati directly. Jagannath Poddar also thought this was not a good idea.

Sevak Sharan said tell Mayawati we are not trying to change her plan, but rather expand it out. Reportedly, an aid close to Mayawati has relatives in Vrindavan.

Madhusudan will use Vrindavan.com to feature the activities of all organizations working for Vrindavan.

GOAL: get 2-3 bullet point news items posted here each day on Vrindavan.com
Noted that the MVDA – is bulldozing land, destroying illegal encroachments per court order – but bvha will still not accept their plan

Jagannath Poddar – Chakravedi – lawyer- let the court appoint? 98 Chakravedi case.

Jagannath Poddar and a representative from Mathura only people appointed by the central govt. MOEF – fund for national lake & river conservation.

Madhusudan Maharaj was appointed the official representative of Govardhan.

Paramadvaiti visited Chidadananda – collected quotes against bridge.

Madhumangal – should be supplied w/ camera.

Jagannath Poddar - we need to get signatures from saints, mahants of Braj.

Need to centralize points for media- to report outside – counteract negative points from local media. Need to keep tabs on what is being said in favor of bridge in the local papers so we can refute these points.

Need to physically approach people for 17th meeting.

Jagannath Poddar – will create mission statement and get petition translated.

Paramadvaiti – went to visit Mathura office to determine MVDA involvement and found no involvement at all. The PWD was in charge, but they had no proper plans either – the govt has been neglecting the town for a long time.

Paramadvaiti Read his letter for the government – it was well-liked, but members agreed a few points should be changed, shortened – could be used for good small mission statement that leaders would support and unify the people of Braj – Jagannath Poddar will work on editing this.

Sri Sri Ravi Shankar is reportedly against the bridge and said he would clean Yamuna from Delhi.

Sevak Sharan will represent alliance at Kumbha Mela.

Shubhananda brought many signatures for heritage and against the bridge. Madhusudan –asked are these petitions real, legal or informal? They are informal.

Manjari thinks both options should exist – formal and informal

The petition finished, in digital edition by 10th

Should we approach Pushpa Sharma?
Madhusudan – has connection with her from a film
Sevak Sharan says – why not?
Jagannath Poddar- it would be a waste of time, but may help heritage status
Paramadvaiti –says we should approach everyone
Prabhat Kumar Sharma of Mathura – helped organize kumbha mela and is being helpful
Bhaktapur has status, why not Vrindavan?
Jagannath Poddar approached Pushpa Sharma before but she was not interested at thattime’
Madhusudan thinks it is good to approach her again.

Next meeting at Madhumangal’s home February 14, 2010 2-4 PM
Manjari – said everyone should pledge to get 20 names of people to contact by this week. A list was made detailing who would contact whom.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Service to the Dham is Bhakti


Prema Narayan Das asked:
Destroy the holy dham? how does one destroy what is eternal? I don't have the vision to see the glories of that land regardless of man-made infrastructure. My param guru maharaja told we are at the mercy of the environment, so all our energy should be spent towards harmonization of our minds with the environment. I think it's so we can try to serve undisturbed. Also I think if Krishna didn't want something to happen it wouldn't happen.
Everyone should act according to their faith. But if you want to know the siddhanta preached by Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati and Bhaktivedanta Swami, then it is this: The world is real. It is Krishna's energy. Devotional service means engaging all the senses of this body in Krishna's service. That way the body, mind, and actions are all spiritualized.

How do we do that? By making the material energy more closely resemble the spiritual.

What is the spiritual energy? It is the idealized concept of truth, beauty and love.

In the language of the Gaudiya Mission, service done in this mentality is called "preaching," but it actually should be understood in much broader terms than simply speaking about Krishna.

Words are the most powerful tools in shaping our consciousness, but they are only part of the story. Our minds are the clearing house of all sensual information, therefore as far as possible we must inundate the mind with spiritualized sense data.
As our mind becomes transformed, it begins to interpret all data in a spiritual way.

The Dham is directly the spiritual energy, but like the Holy Name, it can be covered by our imperfect consciousness. So how does one uncover the consciousness? One performs internal sadhana for purifying the mind with the goal of getting inner vision, but one also engages the senses in external service, attempting to realize the tiny fledgling inner vision externally.

When we serve the Dham, we have to think of results because all action is result-oriented. But we are not attached to the external results. The real results, the real vision of the Dham, will come internally, no matter what results there are externally. The trick is to serve externally, see internally.

The idea of Vrindavan is something like the Christians' Kingdom of God. It exists in the mind, but demands to be reproduced, to the best of our abilities, in this world. Since such an ideal can can never be fully realized in this world, it must at least be made as possible as possible for people to realize it in their minds.

How? By inundating the senses with love and beauty.

The positivists say, “Nothing exists in mind that did not first appear in the senses.” We agree. The only difference is that we say, the world has a spiritual dimension that requires a different kind of processing, through faith.

Our beginning point, our center, our yoga pith, is the Holy Dham. That should be the focal point of our service. They say that siddhi is the ability to make one's inner vision manifest in the outer world.

As you work toward that goal, the inner vision becomes clearer and clearer. The service cleans your heart, and you internally progress in your vision from detail to detail. That is what this is all about.

Just engaging in bhajan without serving the manifest form of Radharani’s heart as the Holy Dham is what is known in this tradition as phalgu vairagya.

Saturday, February 6, 2010

Two Important Upcoming Dates

(1) Feb. 10.

Ramesh Baba is continuing his campaign to stop the blasting in the Braj hills. He and his large group of followers will be surrounding the District Magistrate's offices in Mathura, complaining that he has not done enough to stop it.

A word should be said here about Ramesh Baba, or Sriji Baba. You can read about him at www.brajdhamsewa.org. He is a Nimbarka sadhu, a great kirtan singer and speaker of Hari katha. He is the single most important force for ecology and the preservation of Braj's natural heritage.

Though he is agitating for the purification of the Yamuna and the declaring of the entire Braj area as a green belt, currently his main issue is the mining of the Braj hills--thankfully not Barsana, Nandagaon or Govardhan, but other similar hills in the chaurasi kos area.

Ramesh Baba has felt that the people of Vrindavan and Mathura do not give enough importance to his issues and has written that "Braj is more than just Vrindavan or Mathura." For him to understand and support Vrindavan issues requires that we also recognize and support the issues that are important to him.

The fact is that he has the largest support base of any sadhu interested in these issues in Vrindavan, so his help, even if only in words, is almost an absolute necessity. Ideally, we should find a way of joining forces by creating a publications, websites and public relations efforts that deal with the entire gamut of environmental issues that Braja Dham faces.

So this request is for those who are in Vrindavan on the 10th to find their way to the DM's office and participate in this event.



(2) Feb. 17.

A big meeting of sants and sadhus at the Kumbha Mela in Vrindavan.

I should mention here that there has been quite a bit of work behind the scenes here, for which Paramadvaiti Maharaj in particular is responsible. First of all, when in Hyderabad for the Dharmacharya conference there, at which Dayananda Saraswati presided, he met one of the top men in the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, Ashok Singhal. That led to a meeting the day before yesterday in Delhi, with Singhal and Champat Ray, the joint secretary. Sevak Sharanji was also there.

The VHP is a very big deal. In an earlier event on the day after the Global kirtan, several members of the RSS (Rashtriya Svayamsevak Sangha), a related organization. These people are very disciplined and very active.

First of all, the VHP leadership gave a sympathetic ear to the situation in Vrindavan and suggested that the Vrindavan sadhus be petitioned as far as possible and made aware of the matters related to the bridge and preservation of Vrindavan's heritage.

It appears that they will be in Vrindavan on the 17th and will help to promote the matter at this Dharmacharya conference. So this is a very important event.

Here is a translation of the announcement in the Vrindavan newspaper (Amar Ujala) of Feb. 1, 2010:

The Religious Leaders will meet on Feb. 17 at the Kumbha Mela



The saints and sadhus will share ideas about how to protect the Sanatan Dharma



They will discuss how to increase cow protection and the rebuilding of the Ram temple [in Ayodhya]

Emphasis will be put on giving the Kumbha Mela government status


This year at the Kumbha Mela in Vrindavan, leaders of the Vaishnava sampradayas will discuss a dozen topics related to the protection of Sanatan Dharma. Along with issues related to the Yamuna and the mountains of Braj, they will also freely discuss cow protection and the rebuilding of the Ram temple [in Ayodhya].

Before the Kumbha Mela in Haridwar, representatives of the various maths, etc., will hold an assembly in Vrindavan on February 17. The Vaishnava acharyas have made many proposals concerning the preservation of Hindu symbols and dignity. The pollution of the Yamuna River, the building of the Ram temple in Ayodhya, the preservation of the Kumbha Mela grounds [by the Yamuna in Vrindavan] and giving the Kumbha special government protected status, declaring the entire 84-kos Braja area a green belt, mending pilgrimage sites in Braj, protecting heritage sites from the "land-Mafia" are some of the issues that will be debated at the meeting by the religious leaders.

Besides stopping the blind frenetic development that is going on in Vrindavan, Govardhan and Barsana, with the building of multistoried buildings, etc., it will be proposed that the illegal mining be stopped in the mountains throughout entire area of Braja, parts of which are in Rajasthan, Haryana and U.P., which was witness to Krishna's pastimes and has its ghats on the Yamuna.

It should be noted here, with respect to the pollution in the Yamuna, that many sadhus refused to bathe in the holy river on the day of Shahi Snan (Jan. 30) and notified the government of their displeasure at the situation.

[The promise had been made that a large amount of Ganga water would be diverted to the Yamuna to make the water clear on the day of this important bath, but the amount was insufficient. The DM absolved himself of any blame, but whatever happened, the dirt in the water was too great to be cleansed even by the addition of Ganges. As an eye witness, I can say that there was little difference between the Yamuna on Jan. 4 and Jan 30. I rather doubt that the water was diverted as promised.]

Vishwa Hindu Parishad district captain Harihar Sharma said that they expect Jagadguru Shankaracharya, Jagadguru Nimbarkacharya, Mahanta Nritya Gopal Das of the main encampment in Ayodhya, Sant Jnana Das of the Akhila Bharatiya Akhara Parishad, Swami Chinmayananda, Swami Jnanananda, Sadhvi Ritambhara, Vallabhacharya Vallabha Ray Goswami, etc., to be present.

Needless to say, the issues that Ramesh Baba holds dear are prominent on this list. This shows clearly that supporting him is an essential part of making sure that the issues of Vrindavan get a fair hearing at this meeting. The general issues that are supported by Ramesh Baba are the same as ours, so there should be no controversy, but he has let it be known that he expects support for his pet issues from us.

I do not think that it is too much for him to ask, and I therefore ask anyone who is in the Vrindavan area to go to Mathura on the 10th to join his demonstration, and again on the 17th to the Kumbha Mela to press for the bridge issue and the specific problems of Vrindavan to be addressed at the Dharmacharya Conference.

One other thing: It is clear that many people still do not understood what is at stake in the bridge issue. Many people think that its purpose is to help the pilgrims make the parikrama. They do not realize that it is being built for cars, trucks, buses, tempos and motorcycles, not people. If Ramesh Baba wants Braj to be declared a green belt, let us start by declaring the Parikrama Marg a green belt of protection around Vrindavan town and its temples and lila sthalis.

===================

Just to show that the issue is not dead: From the same issue of the Amar Ujjala, the following article was published just beside the one above quoted:

Bhagavatacharya Haraprasad Shastri declared his opposition to the PIL leading to the stoppage of the half-moon bridge over the Yamuna and called it a conspiracy. In an announcement made on Sunday, Shastriji said that the building of the bridge would help those who want to do the parikrama and that one person from outside had made use of people in Vrindavan to achieve that end.

This reference is to J.P.S. Gill who is a Panjabi Sikh and lives in the old Bharatpur temple on Keshi Ghat and is an opponent of the bridge. But this accusation is entirely false and needs to be countered. Gill is not making any puppets in Vrindavan dance. Those who oppose this bridge oppose it because it is wrongheaded and destructive. It will NOT help those who want to do parikrama. It is only meant to facilitate and increase vehicle traffic, to the DETRIMENT of those doing parikrama. Besides which, it will increase pollution and environmental degradation. It must be stopped.

The Bridge to Nowhere Came From Nowhere

Yesterday Sevaka Sharanji and Paramadvaiti Maharaj took a delegation from the Braj Vrindavan Heritage Foundation to the Mathura Vrindavan Development Authority (MVDA) with the object of finding (1) the master plan for Vrindavan development and (2) the plans for the “half moon bridge.”

The first surprise was that there is no master plan. The Braj Foundation’s master plan, mentioned earlier here in this group's discussions, is apparently about tourism only and does not address infrastructure issues.

Vineet Narain, the person behind The Braj Foundation, who is working closely with Ramesh Baba in Barsana, has been accused by some people of approving or recommending the bridge. This is categorically untrue.

The second surprise was that the MVDA had nothing to do with the bridge and that it is entirely under the Public Works Department.

After getting the necessary maps and documents available at the MVDA, the BVHA delegation moved on to the PWD, where they were first surprised to encounter a crowd of anxious people from Vrindavan. The BVHA representatives learned that the PWD has sent bulldozers to the Parikrama Marg near Madan Mohan and started bulldozing the illegal constructions there, as per the Allahabad High Court decision.

I don’t know that there was any requirement for immediate leveling of these buildings, and without a subsequent plan it seems a little drastic, but at least it is interesting to see that there is some rapid reaction and action.

The PWD gave all the maps requested by the BVHA, though they were a little suspicious at first. However, the big surprise was that the bridge plans were… non-existent for all intents and purposes. The plan provided by Jai Prakash Associates Limited, the contractor for the bridge, was nothing more than an inked-in line over a map of the Yamuna at Keshi Ghat.

Before turning it over, however, the clerk at the PWD whited out the official signatures that gave approval to the project.

The long and short of all this is that the bridge was approved

(1) Without any engineering plans or blueprints
(2) Without environmental impact assessments
(3) Without any municipal hearings, etc.

If the PWD and MVDA did indeed release all the relevant documents to the BVHA delegation, then what we suspected has been confirmed: the project was rammed through without any planning or discussion whatsoever.

Government money was made available and everyone was rushing to think of ways to get that money into circulation as fast as possible without any other consideration.

The plans do, however, show that the intention is there to build a 9.5 meter road, i.e., a four-lane boulevard, on the Parikrama Marg, with a two-meter sand track for pilgrims on foot. Whether that is the best option is worth discussion. I personally would not be in favor of it, as it would split the ghats off from the scenic side of the Yamuna floodplane and in other ways disrupt the organic connection of the Yamuna to the town.

Let's push for the Parikrama Marg to be a Green Belt : harit patti.

Nevertheless, the news is very good for our side. It will be very hard for the government and JP Associates to make the case that they thought this project out thoroughly or consulted with the community, etc. This will make their task on Feb. 23, at the second hearing, very difficult.

What that does, though, is set the scene for the UNESCO meetings, which have now been rescheduled for April 23.

Monday, February 1, 2010

Minutes for Jan. 31 meeting

BVH Alliance
31/1/2010 Meeting, 3 PM
Vrindavan Research Institute
Meeting Minutes

Attendees:
Chandan Goswami
B.A. Paramadvaiti
Sadhu Maharaj
Hari Mohan Malvia
Sevak Sharan
Katie Jo Walter
Jagannath Poddar
Vrindaban Behari
Nirguna devi dasi
Madhumangal Shukla
Manjari Ehrlichman
Prashant Singh
Rajendra Verma
Jagadananda das
Rahul Gopal
Madhuvdan das

Madhumangal Shukla shared an ad posted in the local papers announcing that the MVDA is abiding by the court order. The ad warned that all illegal construction on the Yamuna must stop and that violators would be punished.

Chandan Goswami and Madhumangal Shukla will go to Kumbha Mela to garner support for efforts against the bridge atKeshi Ghat from sadhus and locals. They will use a poster created by VRINDA using images from Chandan Goswami’s presentation shared in the last BVH meeting.

Madhumangal Shukla and Jagannath Poddar gave an update on the stay order regarding the bridge; Construction in metal works is still in progress. It is suggested that pictures be taken and sent to MVDA Commissioner.

Nirguna devi dasi spoke about the need to include the general public and make them aware of the bridge issue. She noted that theatre is a very effective tool for communicating with the public here. She also suggested that BVHA start issuing press releases, as this practice has been highly effective in promoting the work of Food for Life Vrindavan.

Jagadananda das suggested that the BVHA (either officially or not) take out a monthly ad informing the public about heritage and environment issues and development alternatives. Many group members said that this would be an expensive undertaking, so the suggestion was made to publish a 4-page monthly newsletter on our own.

The need to get information about the bridge case and the BVHA’s concerns out to NGO’s working in relevant areas was reemphasized. This need was mentioned at the previous meeting on January 26, but action has yet to be taken in this area.
Sevak Sharan mentioned a threefold plan of immediate action:

I. Promote local awareness
II. Create a master plan for pilgrimage centers
III. Identify on a political level

Discussion took place that BVHA should make it their priority to fight any immediate threats in Braj. This raised the issue of the necessity of gaining the support of Ramesh Baba and Vineet Narain, two powerful figures who have been very effective in addressing issues in the hills of Braj in Rajasthan.

Chandan Goswami said that there are two immediate issues:

I. Fund raising needs to be pursued to cover court costs
II. Members need to set weekly petition signature gathering goals (2,000-3,000 each week was given as an example) and present their progress to the BVHA at meetings.

Chandan Goswami told the group that he and other members who were present at the first BVHA meeting had printable petitions and that these would be copied and shared with the group. It was agreed that signature collection in the greater Braj area was also necessary.

B.A. Pramadvaiti suggested that BVHA members personally visit Pushpa Sharma to let her now the BVHA’s argument and to invite her to participate in BVHA meetings. Paramadvaiti-ji emphasized the importance of trying to include and/or influence local governing individuals and departments before working against them at higher levels.

He also brought up the fact that Sri Madhu Pandit Dasa of ISKCON Bangalore offered to buy and design Keshi Ghat area, but he was turned down because politicians would lose out on contracting money.

Rajendra Verma stressed the importance of reaching out to the greater public and bringing as many people and organizations on board as possible. This sparked a discussion on the possibility of holding two meetings each week: one involving a core group of people who would operate as a steering committee and one including anyone and everyone who wants to show up and discuss ideas presented by the steering committee.

Chandan Goswami asked for an update regarding UNESCO director’s next visit to Vrindavan in February. It was acknowledged that not much has been done in preparation for this. (Note: Secretary has since learned that the visit in fact will not take place until early April). Jagadananda das offered to follow up with Shrivatsa Goswami regarding the upcoming meeting with UNESCO.

After an acknowledgement that BVHA needs someone to follow up with members to make sure they are doing promised work, a position of BVHA Guide was created. This is a position that will rotate amongst various group members. Sevak Sharan was voted in as the group’s first Guide.

B.A. Paramadvaiti mentions the support of Rhagubabu, an employee of the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) and the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ). He adds that GTZ has recently offered to create a Master Plan for Vrindavan.

Paramadvaiti-ji also suggests that BVHA member assess their skill areas and work accordingly.

It is mentioned that someone needs to talk to the School of Planning and Architecture in Delhi and specifically to Professor Nalini Thakur. Katie Jo Walter had pre-existing plans to meet Professor Thakur in the coming week and agreed to talk to her about the creation of a Vrindavan Master Plan.

Katie Jo Walter notified the alliance of her plans to visit organizations in Delhi that have either played a role in trying to conserve Braj in the past or have the potential to do so in the future. These meetings had been arranged for the purpose of Katie’s research. She offered to make organizations aware of BVHA efforts and appeal to them for support. Chandan Goswami gave her permission to approach these organizations as a member of the alliance.

Manjari Ehrlichman proposed that BVHA create a list of all of Vrindavan’s religious leaders so the group can contact them and present them with information. Chandan Goswami said that such a list exists and he has it.

B.A. Paramadvaiti asks that a Meeting Coordinator position be created and filled at the next meeting.

The next BVHA meeting will take place at Kumbha Mela on Sunday, February 7th, from 2-4 PM.